Skip to content
Thornton-le-Dale: a North York Moors village guide

Bangers & Cash

Owning a classic car: what it is really like

By Jon Cosson

An independent guide from the village. Not connected to Mathewsons or the programme. For entries, bidding and the catalogue, go to mathewsons.co.uk. Checked 9 October 2026.

Buying is the easy part. This page is about what comes after: the money, the fuel, the servicing, the paperwork and the people, with my own Triumph Stag as the worked example. It follows on from our guide to thinking of buying a classic car, and every general figure comes from the sources at the foot of the page.

A light blue Triumph Stag with its soft top down parked on a gravel forecourt, seen from the front three-quarter, with other cars and a stone building behind.
Photograph: Jon Cosson

What it costs

The Federation of British Historic Vehicle Clubs surveyed nearly 20,000 owners in 2025. The average owner spends £4,567 a year maintaining and enjoying their historic vehicles, and the average historic vehicle covers 837 miles a year. There are 1,934,178 historic vehicles on DVLA records, owned by about 690,000 people whose average age is 66, and more than a third of them earn under £35,000 a year. Classic ownership is not a rich person's hobby; it is a modest one that adds up.

Specialist insurers offer agreed-value cover, which fixes what they pay if the car is written off, and mileage-limited policies; Everywhen offers bands from 1,000 to 10,000 miles, and Hagerty's classic policy is for cars covering no more than 5,000 miles a year. Owners' club members often get a discount, and Everywhen notes that many policies require the car to be garaged overnight.

Fuel

Most classics should run on E5 super unleaded rather than the standard E10, which carries more ethanol. The Federation advises E5 for every vehicle built before 2000, because ethanol attacks old rubber fuel hoses and seals and draws water into a tank that stands for weeks. Since 2021, filling stations in Great Britain that sell two grades of petrol and at least a million litres a year must keep one as E5. The government was due to review that rule in 2026 and we have not seen the outcome, so the Federation's website is the place to check. Fit ethanol-safe hoses when old ones are changed.

Servicing: little and often

A 1960s or 1970s car was designed to be serviced every 3,000 or 6,000 miles, with grease points to attend to at the shorter interval. Owners who cover 800 miles a year tend to service by the calendar instead, once a year before the season. Older engines with flat tappets need oil with enough zinc additive, known as ZDDP; classic oil makers recommend 1,000 to 1,400 parts per million. Michelin advises replacing tyres at ten years old whatever the tread, and RoSPA has advised against fitting unused tyres more than six years old. Brake fluid absorbs water and is usually changed every two years.

The best thing for an old car is to use it. A proper run, long enough to bring everything up to full temperature, does more good than starting it in the garage and switching off.

View from inside a moving Triumph Stag with the roof down: hands on a wood-rimmed steering wheel, the instrument dials ahead and open moorland through the windscreen.
Photograph: Jon Cosson

The Stag as a worked example

Triumph built 25,939 Stags between 1970 and 1977, and about 8,500 are still on DVLA records, around 6,000 taxed and 2,500 declared off the road. The car's reputation comes from its V8. The alloy cylinder heads corrode if the coolant lacks corrosion inhibitor, which leads to overheating and failed head gaskets; the original water pump was undersized; the timing chains need replacing at around 30,000 miles; and poor earths cause electrical faults. Rust gathers in the sills, wings, scuttle and the A-posts. Most surviving cars have had the cooling system improved, often with an uprated radiator and electric fans, and electronic ignition is a common fit.

Mine is KKH 295N, a 1974 car in French Blue with tan leather, bought from Classic & Sportscar Centre of Malton. It had a mechanical refresh in 2020, including a new water pump and timing chains and skimmed heads. From November 2025 to March 2026 Malton Coachworks restored it, with a return in June 2026 to repaint part of the top: the underside was taken back to bare metal and protected, the top half was resprayed, and a worn second-gear synchromesh meant the engine and gearbox came out, so the gearbox and overdrive were overhauled and the clutch, carburettors, steering rack, suspension, brake lines and fuel tank were done while it was apart. Reassembly found a seized brake valve and a fractured overdrive solenoid, the kind of thing no viewing would ever reveal. The whole job is documented on the Stag Archive; the costs are not published.

Before and after

The rusted underside floorpan of a Triumph Stag seen from below on a workshop lift, with stamped reinforcement ribs, surface rust and patches of red primer.
Before. Photograph: Jon Cosson, November 2025 to March 2026
The underside of a Triumph Stag raised on a workshop lift, showing the freshly painted floor, black steering rack and wishbones, a front coil spring and twin exhaust pipes.
After. Photograph: Jon Cosson, November 2025 to March 2026
The underside of a Triumph Stag's wheel arch on a lift, with light blue outer paint, red primer along the seams and repaired areas, and patches of surface rust.
The wheel arch during the work. Photograph: Jon Cosson, November 2025 to March 2026
The empty engine bay and bulkhead of a Triumph Stag on a workshop lift, with the engine and gearbox out, showing black insulation on the firewall and exposed wiring, brake and clutch lines.
The engine bay empty. Photograph: Jon Cosson, November 2025 to March 2026
A Triumph V8 engine and gearbox out of the car and resting on a pallet on a workshop floor, with a lifting strap around it and a mechanic's booted feet and gloved hand at the edge.
The V8 and gearbox out. Photograph: Jon Cosson, November 2025 to March 2026
A Triumph V8 engine on a hoist strap being lowered into the engine bay of a light blue Triumph Stag in a workshop, with the bonnet off and other classic cars parked alongside.
The V8 going back in. Photograph: Jon Cosson, November 2025 to March 2026

Mathewsons and classic car dealers don't really sell cars; they sell dreams, usually built on cars we remember vividly from childhood. These cars are not objects. They are emotive, and many of us buy them with our hearts rather than our heads. A buyer needs to understand that they are not modern vehicles and are certainly not as reliable. They can, however, be immensely rewarding, opening up a whole new community of friends through very active clubs and events. These cars need to be driven, enjoyed and shown off, and there is nowhere better for that than the North York Moors.

The paperwork

A car in the historic tax class pays nothing but must still be taxed every year, and the MOT exemption is declared at the same time; it does not mean the car can be unroadworthy. The historic class also exempts the car from London's ULEZ, unless it is used commercially, and from the English clean air zones, though not from the London Congestion Charge. Oxford's traffic filters do not exempt historic vehicles, and Scotland's low emission zones use their own rule, exempting vehicles over 30 years old that have not been changed from original. A car that has been substantially altered can lose its MOT exemption, and in extreme cases its identity, so keep records of any changes. If you own a car that has lost its original number, you can apply on form V765 to reclaim it, with old documents and an owners' club's backing; if granted, the number is non-transferable.

The market

Do not buy a classic to make money. In December 2025 Hagerty's UK price guide editor wrote that "the boom times of the post-Covid era are now firmly over", with nearly 80 per cent of values dropping or flat, "but there hasn't been a crash". Buy a car you want to drive, and treat any rise in value as a bonus.

The people

The Federation represents more than 550 clubs, museums and other organisations with over 250,000 members between them, and the owners' club for your model is the best money you will spend. The Stag Owners Club was founded in 1979 and offers a members' insurance scheme, valuations and expert advice. Drive It Day, the Federation's national day for taking historic vehicles out, was on 26 April in 2026 and is held each April.

FAQs

How much does it cost to run a classic car each year?
The Federation of British Historic Vehicle Clubs' 2025 survey found an average of £4,567 a year, for an average of 837 miles. Specialist classic policies, with agreed value, limited mileage and club discounts, can keep insurance costs down.
Can a classic car run on E10 petrol?
The Federation advises E5 super unleaded for anything built before 2000, because ethanol damages old fuel system rubber and draws in water. Larger filling stations that sell two grades must keep E5, though the rule is under review.
Is a Triumph Stag reliable?
A well-maintained one is. The V8's problems come from neglected cooling systems and corroded heads, and most surviving cars have been improved. Buy one with a documented cooling system and timing chains.

FBHVC National Historic Vehicle Survey 2025 (published 20 October 2025) and E10 and clean air zone guidance; gov.uk E10, historic vehicles and vehicle tax pages; TfL ULEZ exemptions; Everywhen, Hagerty and Adrian Flux published policy pages; Millers Oils on ZDDP; Michelin and RoSPA on tyre age; Hagerty UK market commentary, 16 December 2025; The Classic Valuer and How Many Left for Stag numbers; Stag Owners Club; Car & Classic; Wheels-Alive; The Stag Archive; read 9 October 2026.